Germany
98 minutes
5 stars out of 5
----
I went into Salt and Fire expecting something like a standard eco-thriller, or if not a "thriller" then just a movie that involves an ecological disaster and some scientists, but after watching it I have to say I'm a bit ashamed that I'm not yet familiar enough with Werner Herzog to know that no matter how any film of his looks on the outside, it's not going to be "just" anything.
There are two halves to this film that are almost as distinct as the halves in Tropical Malady- i.e., they can basically be considered different movies. The first half is centered on a team of three scientists who travel to Bolivia to present their data on a man-made ecological disaster referred to as Diablo Blanco, for which details are extremely scarce. It's a pretty confusing first half, even though it's actually the most coherent part of the movie, and eventually it segues into a bizarre, dreamlike second half in which a professor from the team of scientists is kidnapped and left on her own on an island in the middle of a vast salt flat near a volcano along with two blind boys named Huasca and Atahualpa and a meagre amount of supplies.
It is as weird as it sounds. There's a quality to this movie that's immensely different from literally everything else out there. It eschews any element of sensationalism or violence and even when there's tension between the main character and her kidnappers, there's no tropes that could be expected in any other scene from any other movie involving a kidnapping. The characters speak every line of their dialogue as if they're reading literary quotations (and believe me, there's no shortage of those, either) and they offhandedly say these totally random things that aren't quite outside the realm of acceptable conversation, but would nevertheless make you look at someone strangely if they were to say them in real life.
I would go so far as to say that in order to properly appreciate any of Werner Herzog's non-documentary work, you have to watch some of his documentaries first, because it dawned on me midway through Salt and Fire that the whole reason the dialogue was so strange was because this is just how Werner Herzog talks. He's writing the script as if it's a story he is personally telling, and once you've heard his narration in other films, you'll know immediately that this is the case. And every single actor, no matter their personal speech patterns, adopts that inflection seamlessly and speaks it like they're fluent in a second language.
I still have no idea what this movie was supposed to be about but I think it's essentially a very, very roundabout way of saying that science needs more humanity in it. There's a lot of literary and historical references that would feel insufferable coming from anybody else but in the context of this film every one of them felt like it had to be there. The soundtrack is unbelievably fitting and just the fact that they used steel cello made me really excited. I don't think this is a film for everyone and especially not if you didn't like My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done, but at the right moment in time if you're in the right mindset it can be phenomenal.